I feel rushed to get a commentary so that I can participate in the study... so I went to Border's bookstore to find one. That was my first mistake. I went to the Bible section of the store and I saw a nice collection of commentaries by William Barclay. I know I have heard his name used before... but I can't remember where. I think it was used in a good way... and that scares me (as you will soon understand why).
So I purchase the commentary relying strictly on the fact that I have heard him quoted... it is expositional in nature... and he is Scottish (OK, that was not really part of the criteria... but Dovie is probably reading this).
I decided to research the guy by way of a Google search, and I found out some very interesting bits of information:
- Barclay does not believe in the literal virgin birth of Jesus
- Barclay does not believe that anyone will go to hell (he believes in Unversalism which says that everyone will be gathered up to heaven).
- Barclay does not believe in the substitutionary atonement of Chris on the cross. (this is at least consistent with his Universalist beliefs, but wrong nonetheless)
So the point of this post is to simply say something that everyone else in the world may know (but I had to learn the hard way)... research authors before you buy their books. I was a little sick to my stomach when I realized that I had just bought a commentary written by someone who does not affirm some of the basic Truths of the Christian faith.
4 comments:
SWEET! I think I'll add "Have I Googled this person?" to my list of speaker/author evaluation questions.
Thankfully, not all of the Scots have such poor theology!
A good Christian (and "Christian") author reference site, if you haven't seen it before...
http://faith.propadeutic.com/authors/authors.html
Just in case anyone hasn't found this already, Dr. Constable's (Mike Cabiro used to use him a lot) commentary is online here: http://soniclight.com/constable/notes.htm
I took a seminary class last fall and Douglas Moo's commentary on Romans was highly recommended, especially for its understanding of the cultural context and how that opens up the meaning of the book.
Post a Comment